Aparajit Advani from Gandhinagar and dispute with Modi
Dilip Patel
Lal Krishna Advani was born on 8 November 1927 on the day of Dev Diwali. He has entered his 100th year.
Advani has always set an example of honesty and integrity in public life.
In 1947, as a young man, he faced the partition of the country. He was forced to leave his home in Sindh, his surroundings and the world he had always known. Everything was left behind and he had to start his life afresh. However, he never had any bitterness or regret about this difficult experience.
BJP leader and former Home Minister and Deputy Prime Minister Lal Krishna Advani, who was elected MP from Gandhinagar six times, has been thrown out of politics by Modi.
Advani’s bungalow is in Sector 2 of Gandhinagar. The Central Government has given a government bungalow in Delhi. Since Lal Krishna Advani was the former Home Minister and Deputy Prime Minister of the country, he has been provided Z+ category security by the Central Government.
As a former MP, he gets lifetime free medical treatment under the Central Government Health Scheme (CGHS) and special concessions on rail and air travel.
The market value of this property in the 2014 election affidavit is around Rs. Crore was shown.
Lal Krishna Advani was elected MP from Gandhinagar Lok Sabha seat a total of 6 times in 1991, 98, 99, 2004, 09, 14. During his visits to Gandhinagar, he mostly stayed at the Circuit House or the BJP office in Khanpur, Ahmedabad.
This VIP seat has been a stronghold of BJP for 35 years.
Vajpayee won once, Advani 6 times in Gandhinagar, former Chief Election Commissioner lost
Amit Shah, who was elected MP of Gandhinagar in 2019, has been elected from here for the second time in 2024.
Modi was made secretary
Modi was Advani’s personal choice. Modi was made the secretary of Gujarat BJP. Advani wanted to strengthen Gujarat. In future the state came to be seen as a strong fortress.
On the recommendation of associates in the late 1980s, Advani included Modi in his state-level team and mentored him. It was Advani who gave Modi an early lesson on how to make the mosque-mandir dispute a national identity and political issue.
Modi came into the national spotlight when he played a key role in organizing Advani’s Modi-Ayodhya Ram Rath Yatra in September–October 1990. BJP got significant political benefits from this journey.
Advani took Modi to Mumbai. This journey was very successful in Gujarat. This system was very simple and it received tremendous public support.
Modi helped Murli Manohar Joshi organize the Ekta Yatra.
came to Gandhinagar
While contesting the Lok Sabha seat in 1991, New Delhi became dangerous for Advani. Modi advised Advani to contest elections from Gandhinagar, a safe seat in Gujarat.
In 1996, when he was forced to resign due to money laundering charges in the Hawala scam, Advani did not contest from Gandhinagar.
After Advani’s election in Gandhinagar, the relationship between Modi and Advani became even stronger. When BJP formed its first government in Gujarat, Kesubhai Patel became the Chief Minister. In a way, Modi was working like a “Super Chief Minister”.
Advani’s special fondness for Modi was well known among both party insiders and observers. Advani played an important role in making Modi the Chief Minister in place of Keshubhai Patel in October 2001.
Akshardham
Advani was an MP at the time of Akshardham attack. He was the Home Minister. On Tuesday, 24 September 2002, there was a terrorist attack on the Akshardham Temple in Gandhinagar. Two terrorists entered the temple and fired indiscriminately with AK-47, killing 30 people and injuring more than 80 people.
NSG (National Security Guards) were called.
Operation Vajra Shakti killed both the terrorists who had entered the temple and rescued all the hostages safely. However, at the very beginning of this operation, JCO (Junior Commissioned Officer) Suresh Chand Yadav was martyred.
Bullets, gunpowder, hand grenades, 12 magazines full of ammunition, dry fruits and dates were found.
Narendra Modi was the Chief Minister of Gujarat.
jinnah controversy
In 2005, when he gave a speech on Jinnah, a party advised him to change his statement, but Advani remained adamant on his point and did not change the statement. But Modi did not openly support Advani.
During a visit to Pakistan in June 2005, Advani wrote in the visitor’s book at the tomb of Mohammad Ali Jinnah: “There are many people in history who leave an indelible mark… but there are very few who actually make history. Quaid-e-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah was one of those few.”
His words about Jinnah did not go down well with the RSS, which still believes in the idea of ’Akhand Bharat’. Advani had to resign from the post of BJP President.
Modi publicly supported Advani, but internally Modi started distancing himself from Advani.
After this the relations between Advani and Modi started turning sour. Modi started maintaining distance from his guru. Advani had to pay the price for this statement and in late 2005 he had to resign from the post of BJP President. The path was cleared for Modi.
Advani was replaced by Modi, who emerged as the new face of the ‘aggressive Hindu face’. The relationship between Guru and Shish has now been replaced by fierce competition.
hostility andThe bond deepened.
The mentor still wished to remain the mentor.
Advani defended Modi.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi considers Lal Krishna Advani his mentor. Advani played a significant role in bringing the BJP to the forefront.
During the 2002 Gujarat riots, when Modi was the Chief Minister, Advani stood in his defense.
Atal Bihari Vajpayee was the Prime Minister at the time. Following the riots, Prime Minister Vajpayee visited Gujarat and advised Chief Minister Narendra Modi to uphold ‘Rajdharma’ (the duty of a ruler). Vajpayee wanted Modi to resign, but Lal Krishna Advani opposed this.
The Riots
In 2002, under Modi’s administration, the incident involving the burning alive of *kar sevaks* occurred in Godhra. In the aftermath of the riots, there was immense pressure on Modi to resign. Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, who visited Gujarat following the violence, offered the same counsel. On April 4, 2002, Vajpayee visited the state; he expressed his deep regret and described the riots as a “stain” on India. He made no secret of his displeasure regarding how the Modi government had handled the situation. “Follow ‘Rajdharma’,” he had urged. Modi remained the Chief Minister of Gujarat, primarily due to Advani’s backing. Although Vajpayee was the Prime Minister, the reins of the party effectively rested in Advani’s hands.
Modi managed to secure his position, and his stature within the BJP subsequently grew. During this period, he applied the political strategies he had learned from Advani.
Over time, differences emerged between the two. By then, the RSS had come to believe that Modi should be made the Prime Minister.
2005
Following 2005, significant political rifts developed between them, centered on the ambition for the Prime Ministership and the leadership of the party.
2011: The *Rath Yatra* and *Sadbhavana Upvas* (fast for communal harmony). In 2011, by undertaking a three-day *Sadbhavana Upvas* in Ahmedabad, Modi signaled his entry into national politics. In response, Advani launched an anti-corruption *rath yatra* (chariot procession) from Bihar instead of Gujarat. Nitish Kumar, an opponent of Modi, initiated a separate march, which angered Modi and led him to boycott the BJP National Executive meeting in Delhi.
The Goa Convention Controversy
In June 2013, at the BJP National Executive meeting in Goa, Modi was appointed chairman of the 2014 election campaign committee. Advani, who opposed this decision, remained absent from the meeting. He subsequently resigned from all his positions within the party.
Relationships
Lal Krishna Advani resigned from the party’s three primary bodies—the National Executive, the Parliamentary Board, and the Election Committee.
In his resignation letter, Advani wrote that for some time, he had found it difficult to reconcile himself with the party’s current functioning and the direction in which it was heading. He wrote, “I no longer feel that this is the same idealistic party that was built by Dr. (Shyama Prasad) Mukherjee, Pandit Deendayal (Upadhyaya), Nanaji (Deshmukh), and (Atal Bihari) Vajpayee—a party whose sole concern was the nation and its people. Today, most of our leaders are preoccupied only with their own personal agendas.”
Fifteen years later, in 2013, Advani felt that his time had finally arrived—the time to lead the nation as Prime Minister. But that was never to be.
He was sidelined by someone who had once been very close to him.
(His resignation was later withdrawn following intervention by the RSS.)
The BJP National Executive meeting in Goa marked the end of the relationship between Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi and Lal Krishna Advani. Advani had proposed the formation of two separate committees for the election campaign; he had also insisted that if only one committee were to be formed, Modi should serve merely as a coordinator, not as the chairman. The debate continued for three days. In the end, Advani’s position was not accepted.
Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi was appointed as the chairman of the BJP’s election campaign committee. With this, the Atal-Advani era came to an end. Furthermore, the four-decade-old mentor-protégé (guru-shishya) relationship between Modi and Lal Krishna Advani also concluded.
September 2013
Candidacy for Prime Minister: In September 2013, when the BJP Parliamentary Board declared Modi as its candidate for Prime Minister, Advani strongly opposed the move and did not even attend the meeting.
After the Modi government came to power in 2014, senior leaders like Advani and Murli Manohar Joshi were removed from the active decision-making process. They were relegated to an advisory board.
Gandhinagar
A ‘VIP’ constituency: The Gandhinagar Lok Sabha seat has always been considered a ‘VIP’ constituency. Former Chief Minister Shankersinh Vaghela was also elected as an MP from this seat.
In the 1999 elections, former Chief Election Commissioner T.N. Seshan contested against the BJP candidate, L.K. Advani, as a Congress nominee.
In that election, T.N. Seshan was defeated by a margin of 188,944 votes.
The BJP won this seat for the first time in 1989, and it has remained with the party ever since.
Vajpayee contested and won from both Lucknow and Gandhinagar. BJP’s Vijay Harishchandra Patel won the subsequent by-election.
L.K. Advani served as the MP from this constituency consecutively from 1998 to 2014.
In 2019, the BJP dropped Advani and fielded Amit Shah from this seat.
The BJP won all 7 assembly segments: The Gandhinagar Lok Sabha constituency comprises 7 assembly segments—Gandhinagar North, Kalol, Sanand, Ghatlodia, Vejalpur, Naranpura, and Sabarmati. In the 2022 Gujarat Legislative Assembly elections, BJP candidates were elected from all these seats. Bhupendra Patel, the MLA for the Ghatlodia constituency, is currently the Chief Minister of the state.
There are 3.5 lakh Thakor voters.
There are approximately 2.5 lakh Patidar voters, about 1.5 lakh migrant voters, around 1 lakh Kshatriya voters, and a total of 13.16 lakh voters from other castes. (transleted from gujarati by google)





